Beyond the Case
A podcast where global leaders from the Harvard Business School Owner/President Management (OPM) community join in a personal capacity and share the real decisions, failures, and mental models behind building enduring companies.
This podcast is independent and not affiliated with Harvard Business School.
Beyond the Case
Leading OPM into Its Next Chapter: The Vision of Its New Chair - Eugene Soltes
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Eugene Soltes, HBS Professor and the new Chair of OPM, shares his vision for taking the programme into its next chapter. He believes OPM is arguably HBS's best platform for bringing its intellectual resources to life because its participants are already successful, ambitious leaders who are hungry to grow further. What makes the OPM community special is the quality and diversity of the cohort: accomplished people from different industries, backgrounds and geographies who can learn as much from one another as they do from the faculty. The OPM experience also creates rare friendships and connections, alongside the opportunity to step away from the demands of business and reflect on life and leadership.
Soltes wants to make OPM a continuous journey, extending learning and engagement beyond the three years through pre-programme preparation, connections between modules and an alumni initiative he calls OPM Plus. He also offers a behind-the-scenes look at the extraordinary preparation that goes into HBS case teaching: faculty refine their teaching plans, adapt to each cohort and receive mentoring from experienced professors. And, of course, OPM is not all work. The shared experiences, socialising and partying are part of what makes the community and its relationships so memorable.
His broader message to business leaders is that sustainable growth requires building organizations that do not depend entirely on their founders, and that emotional intelligence and the ability to understand people are just as important as intellectual horsepower.
Here are the Top 10 Takeaways from the conversation:
- OPM is HBS's best platform for putting academic ideas into practice.
- The quality and diversity of the cohort are OPM's biggest strengths.
- The peer relationships are often more valuable than the classroom experience.
- OPM offers rare time away from business to reflect and reset.
- OPM should evolve into a continuous learning journey beyond three years.
- OPM Plus could keep alumni connected to new HBS research and faculty.
- The most engaged participants are those who are fully present.
- OPM needs more HBS cases featuring its own participants and their businesses.
- HBS professors constantly refine their cases and teaching methods.
- Founders must learn to build leadership teams that can run the business without them.
Books:
Everyone, welcome to this episode of Beyond the Case, a podcast where global leaders from Howard Business School's OPM community join in a personal capacity to share the life lessons, mental models, and decisions which go behind building enduring companies. I'm very honored today. We have Eugene Solz uh as a guest. He is a professor at HPS and also the new chair of the OPM community. So I'm very, very honored to have you here, Eugene. How are you?
SPEAKER_01Great and thrilled, thrilled to be here and trying to step in some uh very large shoes as well.
SPEAKER_00Eugene, just for the benefit of the listeners, could you give a very quick introduction on yourself and your background?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um I've uh I've had the privilege of being on the faculty at HBS since uh 2009. Uh much of uh that time has been in a variety of our different exec ed programs, PLD, GMP, uh, and now OPM. Um I'm uh well, you could say a financial economist by training, but my uh work and research and passion, uh, I like to one hand call organizational conduct and culture. But to those in OPM that know me, uh what I really focus on and study is all the skeletons in the closet. So anything you'd prefer not to have happen within your organization, anything from uh fraud uh to uh harassment to money laundering, anything that you'd prefer to avoid uh is the stuff that uh I've been fascinated to figure out how organizations can prevent that, identify, and uh try to respond effectively when they uh unfortunately sometimes do occur.
SPEAKER_00So despite dealing with such uh sensitive topics, how do you always manage to have a smile on your face? You're always
SPEAKER_01smiling. It's a bit
SPEAKER_00suspicious.
SPEAKER_01Maybe that's my my balance because yeah, otherwise I guess I I live in a world that would otherwise be very, very uh very dark. But uh, you know, ultimately, you know, I'm really interested in people and how people and organizations operate. And one really interesting way is you see when people are are are stressed and organizations are pushed, um, you know, how people respond. So I like to think if I really study people and organizational psychology, uh, just with uh the asymmetric uh downside risk.
SPEAKER_00Have you always been interested in this? Uh was this what you saw yourself growing up and doing as well?
SPEAKER_01No, my gosh. My, I mean, I so when I was in college, I actually thought I was gonna go work for a hedge fund or a bank. I uh after spending one summer at uh investment bank and getting there every day at 5:30 and leaving at 11 to do what I think of as three substantive hours of work, I thought, you know, maybe if I get a graduate degree, I can at least not be the last, like the first person to leave and the last person to exit. I can be like at least the associate. So I wanted to get like an MBA in JD, and I went to one of my faculty of very famous economists uh named Marn Feldstein and asked him to write a letter of recommendation. He said, Eugene, I think it's great that you want to go to grad school. However, I think you should get a PhD instead. So I'll write one to a PhD program, but not an MBA or JD program. Uh that made up my next fate. So I decided, oh, I guess I'll get you get a free MBA in the process. So I got an MBA and then PhD at the University of Chicago. I thought again, I was gonna go work at a hedge fund, but I was writing, finishing up my dissertation right at the point that Lehman was falling apart in 2008, 2009. And I said, you know what, maybe I'll come back to that. So I put my dissertation out of job market, and then uh among other amazing places I got an opportunity, I uh had that chance to join HBS. Uh, I joined, not thinking that this might be the place I would spend the rest of my life. In part, anyone that joins here should be humble enough that our tenure process is really hard. So you probably on average won't make it through. Um, and by some luck and and a lot of work later, uh, I'm so privileged and fortunate to still be here. So uh that was my long, unexpected circuitous path to HBS academia, and then you know, my own research area too.
SPEAKER_00Phenomenal. And then congrats on uh becoming the chair of the HBS program. Uh, what does disappointment mean to you personally? Um, how did the opportunity come about?
SPEAKER_01OPM is, I mean, it's such an incredible community because you have, as a faculty member, and and I don't know how many MBAs listen to this, but uh but I'll still put it frankly, you know, we teach things in our MBA program with the hope that 10 or 20 years later they'll use it. That's that's sometimes a little frustrating to faculty. Like we're in a we're applied social scientists. We want to teach things that are relevant and people can use today. And that's both an opportunity and challenge to make sure our work is relevant. There is simply no better community to HBS than OPM to really put a put our kind of everything we can offer intellectually onto the table and see if it works in practice. And that's why it's the best group to be with um in the school. Uh and so it's it's a really exciting one. Um, it's also the area that we just have so much demand and excitement. Um, you know, a lot of people have questioned when you're 25, should an MBA be the best place to spend the next two years or should you get out there in the workforce? Um, I think what's really cool about being an OPM is that everyone is has actually reached this point of success and is seeking something more to level up more, not just professionally, but also personally. And you see the community and the relationships. Um, it is what I think is where I see management experience, a management journey. It's just so perfected from what our vision and mission is at HBS. Um, so it's just thrilling to be a greater part of it.
SPEAKER_00Um, and and you're taking this position from uh Deepak Malhotra, so you have big shoes to fill.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that that's the only downside. I mean, uh not, I mean, if I go go back, I have I have uh many giant shoes to fill. And I think that's the the only uh intimidating uh part is there, there's there's uh there's a a lot to even just to maintain, just already the incredible program that it is. And already I will say OPMers are not short of giving ideas of how we should even do more uh and better. But that's the thrilling because I feel so fortunate that if the main thing that we're falling short on is that people want us to not end the journey in three years and figure out other ways to even build it further, much like OPM has already done, I will say, on its own with Ignite and other programming, that's an amazing uh problem to try to solve.
SPEAKER_00What's your vision for OPM? Uh, what do you want to preserve, change or introduce, and how do you see it evolving over the next decade?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think right now, as I see OPM is a it's a three-year pro from the HBS, what we we are offer able to offer here. It's a three-year program. As you know, that's pretty incredible because other than some doctoral students that are here for five years, it's the longest program uh of it's longer than MBA program in terms of just the duration in the ability to connect people over time within the program and with faculty. But it's it's still three years. And what I guess I would like to imagine is more of a it's a continuous journey. And so, for example, before you come on campus, we have people with very different experience with AI. I would like to figure out ways before people arrive on campus that we can start leveling up. For example, on some of the toolkit that I think people, there's a lot of hunger on. Between the different modules, can we offer some really interesting programming that can help connect people within the program to one another? So it's not a whole year that goes by, but even some things in between. And then I'm most excited, what can we do after the program? Um, I love to uh create a program uh on my little notes I have here called I call it OPM Plus for my own uh that every week, uh every year going forward, we bring the faculty that are doing new and innovative work. All we know everything you've done OPM. What are some new highlights in that we can people come back to? I'd love to also think that we could offer, maybe in a way to make it manageable, virtual programming for key leaders with inside OPM organizations. So it's sufficiently flexible, also accessible to a broader group of people. So um I have gobs of ideas. Uh now we just need to uh need to work on executing them.
SPEAKER_00You know, OPM participants are already successful business owners, the leaders. Um, what do you believe the program is fundamentally designed to achieve for them? How should they gain beyond the classroom?
SPEAKER_01I I would love to believe is is the what we do in the what I call the classroom, classroom, the cases and and lectures would be the most valuable part. But I think that would be uh that would be just wrong. Um, I think what we offer in the classroom with the cases and what the faculty do, we offer some information and knowledge and frameworks for people to really then build on with their peers outside of the classroom. And I think the two most valuable parts of of OPM are first the peers and their be able to exchange information with one another on both a professional but also personal side. I mean, how I think about it, uh I guess now I'll expose my age. I'm I'm I'm 45. I will say once you're at a certain age, I think it's somewhere probably in your late 30s, you don't really get to meet that many new people. Like it's it becomes harder, like new people that you respect and are really excited to spend time with. I will say you can kind of name people on like one hand, and that's like every couple years. I mean, we offer this place like uh OPM where you're gonna be immediately connected to like a hundred plus people. I will say many of which, not all, but many of which will be like really close people. Some because of where they live, some their experience and background, some because they're in the same industry, some in the same region. That's really special. Um, that's hard to come by in life. Uh, I think the other thing OPM offers is like everyone is successful, as you noted. And but everyone's also really busy, both with their professional and personal obligations. You know, normally when you take some time off from work, it's to get away, it's to go to, you know, the nice beach, just to go to Maldives or the Caribbean, get away from it all. We're offering something a little different, which is it's kind of a beach vacation, but it's also to get away from the grind of your your email and responding to all your other employees and customers, all their demands. So you can build and figure out what you want to do for yourself professionally and how you want to change and evolve personally. And us giving you that time away for a couple of weeks and why I think it's important we're together here in in Boston, so we can kind of rip you away uh for that for that precious time is is so powerful. And I think why it's so inspiring to hear everyone I speak talks about this transformational experience that they have.
SPEAKER_00What do you guys do behind the scenes before we come on campus? How do you guys prep for any new cohort or any um any uh returning cohort as well?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so first we want to continue to figure out uh what are new topics and new material that we can bring into the classroom. Um, I mean, the world is changing very quickly. Uh AI is among other areas, so trying to figure out how do we bring new tooling, new frameworks, new innovative work and research. Uh, so one of my primary responsibilities is to figure out, look around the campus and figure out who I can draw into the program. Um, sometimes I'm gonna give a little teaser to get them in and get maybe in just for a session uh with a new book they wrote. And then once they see how awesome the OPM program is, I'll convince them to come back for a couple more sessions and more and more uh thereafter. So a lot of my work is about what we can make that composition of the journey around, both the faculty, but also I want to think as I'm describing some of the other programming that we can make as a broader journey. Um behind the scenes, we have an incredible staff that are are managing the millions and millions of frankly other pieces of getting all the materials organized to you and and and trying to make it a uh comfortable um uh but but comfortable, I should probably say also demanding uh experience.
SPEAKER_00Um from the guys that uh get a lot out of the OPM program, what are they doing differently in your opinion, after having seen such uh such a huge number of uh participants be alumni today? What are the guys who extract the most from this program doing differently?
SPEAKER_01So the the first most key part is being all in. Um I will say uh we're always battling with our norms. We want you to be on, which I mean look, put away your cell phone, put away your laptop. Uh you might have to answer, I know, a couple notes at night, but but really try to focus and dedicate that time uh while uh while you're on campus. And I know that's hard. Um, you know, in the session we were just doing today, uh, I know as we hit the third week uh in those last couple days of the program, a lot of OPM organizations are looking for their leadership uh and they need it to continue growing. And, you know, some of the sessions we're doing today is how do we design organizations that can be more effective and sustainable because you're designing the processes and systems and support to delegate those responsibilities and that leadership to others. And I think a lot of OPM organizations are at this cost, they're getting there. This is why they're as successful as they are, but they still rely on that owner, president, founder to really advance the organization. And so one of the things I'm excited is how do we push to that next layer where it releases the OPMer from that day-to-day and allows them to have that even broader reach because they are able to delegate, but also trust that the people they have in the place will carry on those responsibilities and the vision that they have.
SPEAKER_00Okay, tell us how did you land your gig with Howard Business School? What led you to pursue this school?
SPEAKER_01Uh, so I mean, HBS. I'm sure it's a not different when you look at a lot of OP members and thinking, I mean, Harvard's special. Uh, I mean, I should note, I I did my undergrad here. I spent my last senior year, my dorm actually overlooked the business school campus. Um, and I the idea of being, frankly, even a student here when I first attended college was was humbling. I remember getting that acceptance letter. And uh honestly, the only thing that was even more I will say I think anyone should feel a sense of gratitude, almost surprise when they get that admissions letter. Um, getting that call that I could potentially have the opportunity to join the faculty, even it might only be for three years, and then they will send me out to somewhere else was was really just such an opportunity. And it's because it's a everyone here, faculty and students, they're they're creative, they're ambitious, they're thoughtful, they're mission-driven. And to be part of an organization that is so mission-driven and people say yes. Uh, this is how I can get people into OPM. If someone writes a new book, I'm gonna ask them to join OPM for a session. They will always say yes. Um, how many organizations can you say? And that might be a Saturday session or it might be a the late Friday session, people will rearrange their travel schedules. Like being an organization that is mission-driven with smart, intelligent-driven people, that everyone says yes, um, it's a special place to be. And it's why you don't see a lot of faculty, you know, once people have the, if they're fortunate enough to get tenure, you don't see a lot of turnover like you might see at other universities. People are always challenged to then level up to do something else. And maybe my personal, this is uh is to to have the privilege of being uh chair of OPM, which I I can promise is also also a challenge. OPMers are grateful and amazing. They're a demanding group, a demanding group too. As they should be, I should note.
SPEAKER_00Are the new professors or even existing professors trained on the way they deliver a case uh and how they um interact with not just let's just say OPMers for now?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I should note, uh, I I can give a funny story here. So, I mean, most of the time when you go to most universities, even top universities, teaching is is kind of what pays the bills and your task to it. Uh and the the goal of especially if you're a successful researcher, is how can I get my teaching rolled down and do less of it? Uh at HBS, it's a really different world. Like what we talk about in our hallway. If I go outside my hallway and talk with faculty and colleagues of all ranks, uh, we talk about what case we taught, what worked well in the classroom, what things we learned. Um, but that's the culture. But the culture is also one we we spend a lot of time, I will say, training kind of the art. And there's always work to be done. Um, I will say the first class. So if you go, Opium, we don't have, we effectively we don't have any what I call junior faculty in the classroom. But if you go to our some of our other programs, our MBA, you'll see people that have just joined the school, they've been here one, two, or three years, and you're gonna see senior faculty.
SPEAKER_00People
SPEAKER_01been around for 10, 20, 30 years sitting in their classroom. That's part abalative, but that's part mentoring, as we're trying to develop. And I'll never forget the first time, this is my second week at HVS, I had a celebrated faculty member who was here for 40 years sit in my class. This is, you know, two weeks in. And I saw him in the back of the room with a sheet of paper. And I could just see he was looking up and writing something like every like every 30 seconds. I was like, what is this guy doing? And I'm sitting there, of course, still trying to write on the board, teach a class, mind what's going on. And then I'm still half curious, half worried about what is he writing on the sheet of paper. And what he was writing is that he actually held up after me, he sat down, we had a meeting about it, held up, and he said, Here's where you were standing every 30 seconds for the 90-minute discussion. And you're like, I can guarantee there's not one other school in the country where you're gonna get evaluated on your and he described your footwork by a senior faculty member. And his point was that much like I was trained to stand there like a lecture, I kind of moved back and forth, but I was in this really small bubble. And he's like, You need to embrace people, you need to go up the aisle, you need to move, go to the side, go close to people, engage them. And he's like, here's the opportunities. And we had an hour-long discussion about where there are opportunities to approach different parts, different people in the room, different aisles. And he said, part of teaching a great case is your feet work and how you move. And I've always reflected on this of like how extraordinary to have multiple hours discussed about where you stand in the room when you're giving a case. Uh, I can assure that's only at HPS, but it's left a, you know, 16 years later, it's 17 years later, it's left a deepen impression. It's something I still routinely think about.
SPEAKER_00Does it also um uh is there also some training around uh interaction with the participants and you know what is a good balance between the number of comments that come in versus moving on from a topic?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. I mean, we do we do some more formal, so we don't just do footwork training. Um we do a lot in terms of thinking about the organization, even prepping. Like we have this case, but like how to create a narrative, how to make it engaging and nonlinear, um, when we can push people, when cold calling. I mean, and and it's interesting in some of the cases that you know, I will do some of the more like technical cases, less so so in OPM, but you know, technical cases that look like financial engineering, a lot of people are really uncomfortable with that material. So if you'll cold call less and and invite people more to participate. Um, OPMers are a confident group. Um, people, I will say, you learn when people are engaged because they start arguing, they raise their hand, you have to control the discussion versus one where you have to pull it out of people. So we also spent a lot of time, and it's you know, it's something OPMers are really fortunate. They have a very mature and very experienced um uh teaching uh faculty. Um, but I will say part of it going to OPM is learning what makes OPMers different from AMPers, PLDers, you know, in other programs. Um, even the dynamics that you see evolve between OPMers and learning to evolve, even how you do a case based upon what the audience. Um, it's again, that's what makes it challenging. I can say, you know, I've been what an OPM for four years, and literally the cases I'm doing twice a year, I'm literally rewriting my case plan each time and adapting it as I learn each time what can make it a little bit better. And it'll never be right. I know I'll do I can do this for another decade. I'll still not have it just right. But my hope is every time it'll be a little bit better than the last. And I will say that's the philosophy that we have. And I will say, all the faculty, how do you make it just a little bit better?
SPEAKER_00Very well explained. How do you go about identifying your case uh protagonists or doing case research, understanding what you want to write the next case on?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, OPM, I think this is one of the opportunities we have actually a lot of opportunities and frankly some work to do is OPM organizations are different. Um where they sit, you know, the where they operate, the industries they focus on, um, the role that the OPMer plays within the organization. And one of the things I really hope that we can create more of is more what I call OPM specific cases,
SPEAKER_00where
SPEAKER_01the protagonist looks a lot like the OPMer uh within it. Um, I will say right now, for a lot of the cases we're we're focusing on, is what are interesting gaps in our Understanding a phenomenon. Great cases. And it's something I think OPMers learn about over time as they're in the program. It's not because it's the newest case. In fact, I think increasingly, especially in OPM, I'm trying out cases in other programs. A lot of the cases I'm doing, I know one of the ones that I know people enjoyed, it was like from the 90s. It's like 30 years old. But the power is every single thing in it is just as applicable today and applicable. It's also has a style in which the lessons will evolve in discussion. It's so good because we understand a great, what I call teaching plan associated with it. And so I will say sometimes you'll see in OPM cases that you'll look at the date and you might laugh, being like, oh my God, why is he teaching a case that's 30 or 40 years old? That's a feature, not a bug. That's because I know I know how I'm going to bring this around and make it seem like it was something that could have happened last month. Um, but we've learned a little something in the last 40 years, but it shows you we still haven't solved it because this is still rising and people can relate to that.
SPEAKER_00You've also written some books, right? Uh I uh I think three or four of them, one of them being uh why they do it. It's on corporate fraud misconduct. And so, given uh your research, the changes ahead, uh that expected, what do you think um will become important for entrepreneurs over the next decade?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I won't spoil everything on here in case we have future OPMers listening, since I do like to weave a couple of the fun things into some of the sessions. Um, but uh one point that that I will make is that you know, you look at the work that I do, which is generally uh the first book was actually on very, very prominent executives and leaders who subsequently ran into significant reputational and regulatory issues. Um, you know, I spent on the order of seven years interviewing 50 of the more prominent people who fell fell into this position. Um, I should know a whole pile of them were HBS alum. There is no one sitting in a room at the end of OPM or any of our programs at HBS that thinks they're gonna do anything but something laudable. Maybe it's make a pile of money, maybe change their industry, maybe they want more, more what I call respect within the world. But I would say it's laudable in some in some way. They don't think they're gonna go out and do something that's gonna frankly get them in a headlines. But I will say the evidence is different. It's it's still infrequent, but there's enough cases of it showing that something happens in our environment. And that's the area that I've been fascinated to explore. How do well-intentioned individuals that have, I will say, laudable objectives that are smart and thoughtful and actually really successful in almost all instances find themselves facing these awful positions. Um, you know, this week when we're talking about this, you know, Nvidia's in the news. I mean, you couldn't have a more inspiring company about how it's changing the world and its technology. But you see the turmoil, turmoil, it's leader and now the company, and now frankly, the entire AI infrastructure that's surrounded by because of some decisions that were made. And so we need to understand that. And some people are saying, you know, on one side, is this a governance? It is this individual responsibility and leadership, it is this governmental policy. It raises a whole host of questions, and that's what makes it such an interesting area to understand and study. But again, it's human psychology, and that's if you're trying to understand incentives and how they power people to do things effectively and well, you also need to affect where that occasionally has people go off on the wrong track, uh, sometimes without even really uh always appreciating and realizing it.
SPEAKER_00Phenomenal. Um, in closing, I have just a couple of questions, which I typically like asking all the participants. Um if you were sitting against a younger version of yourself, what advice would you give him?
SPEAKER_01So here's the part that's been most humbling, and I will say I joined HBS. Um you think that what I call horse horsepower, uh, and I will say like pure grit and intellectual horsepower, like wins the day. Um increasingly, I guess what I see is we need some amount uh of that, but it's people that have high what I call EQ and have the ability to understand people really, really well that ultimately are not just successful people on the professional side, but personally the kind of people that you admire, respect, and and want your kids to grow up to. Um, and I think sometimes that's underplayed, particularly in ambitious high-performance organizations. Um, a place like Harvard, a lot of kids, uh, parents want their kids to go there and they are pounding all the studies and all the math and all the grades they need to get with neglecting the other parts to create well-rounded individuals, which is ultimately what creates a well-grounded, successful, happy person. And so I think I've spent a lot more time, both with myself and certainly my kids, thinking about how do we, how do we cultivate that balance, particularly in a world that has more and more expert expectations that you do more and more things faster as well. How do you how do you stay grounded?
SPEAKER_00Amazing. Lastly, uh, is there a book you've read in your life which has influenced the way you think?
SPEAKER_01So I I collect, I so I'm a I'm a book collector, hoarder. Um, I joke. Many of those I can't read since most of those are 17th century books um and in languages. Uh uh uh but see, a great, a great book. Um Jonathan Haidt, uh who's a uh psychologist NYU.
SPEAKER_00Uh
SPEAKER_01uh so I'm actually gonna go, great book. That's great. I'm gonna go his next book, his next book, The Righteous Mind. The Righteous Mind. Um it's the best book in a world that it seems so divisive when it comes to things like politics and religion. It it takes a social psychology view uh of the world. I found it, I found it just a brilliant way of better understanding. I think some of the complexity that I feel that we're we're stuck in. We've been in for a while as a society, and I think we're gonna be in this way uh going to the future. So it's one of my books that I've I've actually read several times, look back on, and I think really says something deep and fundamental about human nature.
SPEAKER_00Very nice. Thank you very much. I know it's a very busy day for you, and you were kind enough to take a few minutes out of that to speak with me. So I appreciate that. Um, I'll see you on campus again, I think, tomorrow.
SPEAKER_01Well, uh, it's been my absolute pleasure, and I I hope to see many more OPMers in the future that might be listening to this. Um, both those that graduate in the past at reunions and other events, and then maybe to future OPMers uh as well. Uh thrilled. Thrilled.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Eugene.